Friday, May 7, 2010
birth cirtificates
I guess what still lingers with me is the whole intersex baby thing. I find it so fascinating, and something I hadn't known very much about until I read Fausto-Sterling. The diagram she has in her book, where sex lies on a continuum for a newborn baby has been stuck in my head since I first saw it. And when it is ambiguous at birth, how do you go about deciding? You can check levels of sex hormones in the blood or what the chromosomes say. That won't always answer the question. The stories about those who had a sex change operation at birth, and then became super depressed or angry later on...might just go to show that there's an actual identifiable sex that a person is supposed to live out. Also it shows that a doctor can make a wrong decision regarding the baby's sex. Reversal surgery is potentially more detrimental to the person's emotional state. A lot of talk about holding off on these new-born surgeries is just as controversial, though. Doctors have been saying to wait though, because that way when the child decides for him/herself, at least you haven't damaged anything yet. The problem becomes, what then does a parent put on the birth certificate? In Texas, for example, you aren't allowed to change your birth certificate. So if the parent arbitrarily picks a boy, and then at age 4 the kid decides "I'm a girl", in the eyes of the law she will always be a boy. And she won't ever be able to marry a man. It is that screwed up.
Wow, Texas sucks. Maybe this is just a woefully ignorant question, but why do we have to specify sex on a birth certificate? If it is so like, identifying your baby in the sea of hospital babies purpose, then that maybe makes sense...would it be possible to just have a little continuum on a birth certificate, with a penis on one end and a vagina on the other, and then people just put an X somewhere on it? Obviously, the issue of pronouns/identity/etc still exists, but that could maybe help situations for anyone in Texas...
ReplyDeleteWord. Texas can suck. But (and this is assuming that we could easily change the way people think in terms of gender and sex, ha!) why is that even something that would need to be identified? The care involved in raising a physically healthy boy or girl is not different. Feed, change diaper, interact socially with them. If we introduce a continuum, that will just invite more approximating categories, and then baby books where you can take a test to see where on the scale your kid lies and how to raise him/her to be "that" degree of male/female.
ReplyDeleteand pronouns are lame.